Lake Mary Cards and Collectibles

Lake Mary Cards and CollectiblesLake Mary Cards and CollectiblesLake Mary Cards and Collectibles

Lake Mary Cards and Collectibles

Lake Mary Cards and CollectiblesLake Mary Cards and CollectiblesLake Mary Cards and Collectibles
  • Home
  • Contact
  • Services
  • Selling To Us
  • Consigning Your Cards
  • Grading Your Cards
  • Our Inventory
  • About Us

Consigning for Cards or Collection

What we can offer

We have a multitude of avenues to get your cards and collectibles sold if we either are not interested, or our cash office doesn't fit what you were looking for. We handle all the work of getting the item(s) listed & sold, all you have to worry about is getting paid.


In order to complete any of these services, we need the item(s) in hand. We accept shipments or can meet in person. We are located in Lake Mary, FL and are willing to travel to you if necessary. 

eBay Consignment

Our first and most used option is listing your item(s) at a Fixed Price or Auction format on our eBay store. A Fixed Price listing means that users can view your item and either A) Purchase it at full asking price, or B) send in an offer for us to relay to you for acceptance or to decline. An auction is as simple as it sounds, we list the card for a 7 Day Auction, and what it sells for, it sells for.  (Please note: anyone caught bidding on their own items will be permanently banned from ever submitting cards and your items will be returned)


For either of these options, it is mandatory for us to have the item(s) in our possession. 


Our fee's associated with eBay consignment are below

(Please Note: Net indicates that it is the % we take after eBay's fees are taken & the shipping cost is taken | Gross indicates the price displayed on eBay when item sells)


Items with a gross sale price under $100 : 15% of the Net Sale Price

Items with a gross sale price of $100-$999 : 10% of the Net Sale Price

Items with a gross sale price of $1000+ : 5% of the Net Sale Price

Fanatics Auction

We utilize Fanatic's Auction frequently to sell individual Sports & TCG Cards. It is a great place for more rare collectibles and higher dollar cards. There is more strict criteria to utilize this service. Only cards that we deem are worth $200 or more are eligible for this service. 


It is mandatory for us to have the items for this service.


Our Fee Structure is simple...

You will receive 85% of the net sale price of the card after the website's fees. 


Please note: Fanatics Auction utilizes a "Buyer's Premium" system. Any auction won, there is a 20% premium added to the winning bid. You are going to receive 85% of the all in price of the item with the premium included!



Dealer to Dealer Network

This service is only utilized for select, higher end cards ($1000+). We have a network of personally vetted, individual dealers we can present your item to, and receive an offer that we can relay to you. 


It is mandatory for us to have the items for this service.


Our fee structure is simple for this service, 5% of the sale price. 

Want to get started consigning?

Consign NOW

Copyright © 2026 Lake Mary Cards and Collectibles - All Rights Reserved.

  • Home
  • Contact
  • Services
  • Our Inventory
  • About Us

Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept